Do you agree or reject the Lies of P Red Fox offer?

The Lies of P Red Fox offer is a pivotal choice players must face when encountering the mysterious siblings Red Fox and Black Cat in Krat. These two characters can turn into loyal allies or formidable enemies depending on how you respond to their proposal. Whether you accept or decline Red Fox’s request has a significant impact on the narrative, gameplay, and future encounters. If you’re wondering which option is the better one, this guide breaks it all down.

Who are the Red Fox and Black Cat?

Red Fox and Black Cat are memorable NPCs from Lies of P, known for their sibling connection and their role within the Stalkers — a faction committed to tracking and eliminating puppets. They bring not only flair but depth to the story through their complex relationship and dynamic roles in your journey.

Red Fox is bold and relentless, serving as a central figure in a few key questlines. Black Cat, on the other hand, exhibits a more light-hearted and compassionate demeanor. Though both can accompany you during certain segments, they can also become mini-bosses later in the game if your choices put you at odds with them. Red Fox excels with agility and tools like poison mist and grappling hooks, while Black Cat combines agility and ranged abilities for a balanced fight.

Their sibling bond adds emotional weight to the story, as their conflicting values — Red Fox's cold ruthlessness versus Black Cat's hesitation — create a believable tension throughout their questline.

What is Red Fox’s Request?

The Lies of P Red Fox offer presents itself during an encounter in the Malum District. Here, Red Fox and Black Cat ask for your help in attacking the Black Rabbit Brotherhood. Your decision here determines whether they’ll aid you in battle or become adversaries later on.

Accepting Red Fox’s Offer

Choosing to accept the Lies of P Red Fox offer means teaming up with Red Fox and Black Cat. This makes them temporary allies, fighting alongside you as you take on the Black Rabbit Brotherhood. If you maintain a friendly bond with them throughout the game, you can avoid their boss fights and instead share dialogue, exchanges, and even rewards.

Their assistance is especially valuable during tougher segments, as they help take some pressure off your character during combat. Additionally, befriending them leads to a more optimistic narrative route where they survive and recognize you as a trusted ally.

Refusing Red Fox’s Offer

Turning down the Lies of P Red Fox offer ends the encounter quickly, pushing you down a more hostile path. Red Fox and Black Cat will no longer assist you, and from this point on, they’ll treat you as a potential threat. This decision sets you up for boss battles later in the game where the siblings confront you separately.

Although declining the offer closes off certain story interactions, it also introduces more challenging gameplay elements for those seeking a tougher experience. The fights are still manageable if your character is well-upgraded, but they add an extra layer of difficulty.

Should You Accept or Reject the Offer?

Deciding whether to accept or reject the Lies of P Red Fox offer boils down to your preferred playstyle and emotional outcome. If you want a lighter, more emotionally rewarding conclusion, accepting is the better choice. You avoid tragic confrontations, receive assistance during key missions, and gain some unique interactions with both characters.

On the other hand, rejecting the offer is ideal for players looking for greater challenges and more boss fights. You'll fight Red Fox and Black Cat separately, and while it may not change the cosmetic rewards, the journey takes on a darker tone.

What are the Rewards for Accepting or Rejecting Red Fox’s Request

Whether you accept or decline the Lies of P Red Fox offer, the end rewards remain the same. Completing their questline grants you the Red Fox Hat and Black Cat Mask — stylish cosmetic items that don’t offer stat benefits but look great on your character.

Completing the Red Fox Questline After Accepting the Request

The questline tied to the Lies of P Red Fox offer officially starts in Chapter 5. Your choices throughout the subsequent chapters influence the final outcome with these characters. Here’s a full breakdown of how to complete it after accepting their request:

Encounter in the Malum District (Chapter 5)

You’ll first meet Red Fox and Black Cat at the start of the Malum District. Red Fox will ask you to help take on the Black Rabbit Brotherhood. Accepting makes them temporary companions, aiding you through enemy-infested zones as you approach the Brotherhood’s hideout.

Expect a few amusing insults, like being called their “new dumbass,” but they’re loyal allies while you complete the objective. Once it’s done, they’ll leave the area, and you can follow up with them in later chapters.

If you refuse the Lies of P Red Fox offer here, the encounter ends, and you won’t receive their support through this mission. This choice leads to the antagonistic path.

Meeting at the Grand Exhibition (Chapter 7)

Your next meeting happens near the monorail in the Grand Exhibition. Here, Black Cat will request a Gold Coin Fruit. Giving it to him strengthens your relationship and grants rewards like the Quixotic vinyl record and the Beg gesture.

If you don’t have a fruit, they’ll ask for it anyway. You can return to Hotel Krat to collect one from the Gold Coin Tree. Failing to provide it will shift their view of you, and they’ll continue the story with a colder tone.

Encounter in Arche Abbey Outer Wall (Chapter 11)

The final outcome of the Lies of P Red Fox offer hinges on your past decisions. In Chapter 11, if you didn’t help them or give Black Cat the Gold Coin Fruit, both characters become boss fights. These battles are challenging but avoidable.

If you accepted their request back in Malum and gave the fruit in Chapter 7, you can bypass these fights. Black Cat will ask for another Gold Coin Fruit instead of fighting. Giving it to him earns you the Black Cat Mask without combat. Later, Red Fox will also request one last fruit, offering the Red Fox Mask in return if you spared her brother.